Another recent match at 23andMe that had a nice family tree prepared was dad's cousin Jonelle, who was predicted to be 3rd to distant cousin, with 0.22% DNA shared on only 1 segment.
Jonelle has a pretty extensive tree linked to her profile from MyHeritage, but I was not able to find any surname matches. She did have quite a bit of Dutch ancestry, and dad has some Dutch that hasn't been fully researched. Will continue the conversation with Jonelle to see if we can find a connection.
Jonelle does not share any DNA with me.